At the recent IZhO in mathematics there were unusual problems, many of which trolled the majority of participants. P2 was solved by a trick, and many failed to find it. I also did not solve it: during the contest I acted too technically, which did not help. My approach was an attempt to squeeze the desired number between given ones, which is a stronger statement (but, as it turned out, equivalent) that I managed to prove after the contest.
Problem.
Let $$$n$$$ be a positive integer for which there exist positive integers $$$a$$$ and $$$b$$$ such that
Prove that there exists a positive integer $$$c$$$ such that
Official solution
Denote
Adding, we obtain
from which
My solution
Idea.
- We look for values $$$x_c$$$ that are squeezed between $$$a\sqrt{10}$$$ and $$$b\sqrt{11}$$$;
- we prove that such a $$$c$$$ exists and is unique;
- we show that for the remaining $$$c$$$ equality of integer parts is impossible.
Denote
Step 1. Squeezing condition
If
then it immediately follows that
This is equivalent to the inequality
Compute the differences:
Since the denominator is positive, we obtain the equivalent condition
Hence,
where
Step 2. Uniqueness of the integer solution
The length of the segment equals
From the conditions we have
therefore
Thus, at most one integer can lie in $$$[L, R]$$$.
At the same time,
from which
Therefore,
is the unique integer solution; the necessary and sufficient conditions are verified.
Step 3. Absence of other solutions
From the inequality $$$b\sqrt{11} - a\sqrt{10} \lt 1$$$ it follows that
Then
Consequently,
that is,
Similarly,
Hence, no other values of $$$c$$$ exist.







